The Somm Journal

Somm Journal Dec2018-Jan2019

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1061132

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 53 of 116

{ SOMMjournal.com } 53 Chicago photos by AJ Krane How fitting that a luxury icon should serve as the backdrop for Luxicon: In all its mod- ern grandeur, The Peninsula Chicago set a five-star scene for both the tasting and the seminar that preceded it. Ballance's partner for the Windy City edition was Master Sommelier Emily Wines, the Vice President of Wine and Beverage Experiences for Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurants. Their collaboration begged the question of whether there could there be two more auspiciously surnamed guides to lead one through the art of tasting. The pair's detailed insights into the Court's deductive approach started with the Beringer 2016 Oak Knoll District Luminus Chardonnay as a control wine. Ballance stressed the importance of sight in the evaluation process, admitting that she "got burned a couple of times" in the tasting portion of her own exam by, for example, neglecting to observe the cop - pery glints in a glass of Pinot Gris. Though her reputation as a Krug Cup winner preceded her, Wines put everyone at ease by reminding them that blind-tast - ing is no "parlor trick," but rather a practical means for sommeliers to "choose wines that are classic representations of what they should be." "It's one thing to recognize these aromas, but it's another to under - stand cause and effect," Wines continued. To provide another example, Wines next blind-tasted a Penfolds 2015 Bin 28 Kalimna Shiraz, observing that its high color and viscosity likely located it in the New World. She then turned to the nose, adding, "I always try to think about what's driving the wine"—in this case, ex - tracted black fruit laced with everything from olives and toasted herbs to smoke and tar. Similar notes on the palate com- bined with high alcohol and medium-plus yet silky tannins led her to a conclusion: Barossa Valley Shiraz. "Anyone want to challenge what Krug Cup said?" Ballance asked teasingly. Then it was the guests' turn. All they knew about the three reds poured before them was that they'd been chosen in accordance with a theme, but apparently they did an admirable job of evaluating them. Upon announcing the winners, Ballance praised the group for "writing novels" about the Bordeaux blends: the Maison de Grand Esprit 2015 Saint- Estèphe, the Chateau St. Jean 2015 Cinq Cépages, and the Mazzei Tenuta Belguardo 2013 Maremma Toscana. The scholarships were awarded to Elizabeth Kowal, Assistant Wine Buyer at Geneva Wine Cellars and a sommelier instructor at the College of DuPage in Glen Ellyn; Ryan Baldwin, Head Sommelier at the Waldorf Astoria Chicago; and Andy Lock, Sommelier at Cask & Ale in Madison, Wisconsin. Everyone, however, benefited from the exercise: "I'm Certified and deciding whether to go for Advanced, but my career's been exclusively Italian and my biggest stumbling block is blind-tasting," said Anika Ellison, Sommelier at Chicago's Spiaggia. "What's helpful for me is discuss - ing indicators, and they did a good job of spelling those out." Emily Wines, MS and Vice President of Wine and Beverage Experiences for Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurants, with Treasury Wine Estates Education Manager Gillian Ballance, MS. From left to right: Andy Lock, Sommelier at Cask & Ale in Madison, WI; Emily Wines, MS; Gillian Ballance, MS; Elizabeth Kowal, Assistant Wine Buyer at Geneva Wine Cellars; and Ryan Baldwin, Head Sommelier at the Waldorf Astoria Chicago. San Francisco photos by John Curley Somms enjoy the spoils of the Luxicon portfolio with a bird's-eye view of San Francisco. For the San Francisco Luxicon tasting held at the Mark Hopkins, Ballance teamed up with fellow Master Sommelier Chris Blanchard for an inspired orientation of the Court's tasting grid before a tough double-blind tasting. Blanchard, the Director of Sales at Vine Hill Ranch in Oakville (he formerly served as the wine director at the now-

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of The Somm Journal - Somm Journal Dec2018-Jan2019