Machinery Lubrication magazine published by Noria Corporation
Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1103301
56 | March - April 2019 | www . machinerylubrication.com previous versions of AS4059 are based on particles greater than 6 microns, whereas classes from this revision are based on the number of particles in each of the size ranges except the smallest, 4 microns. AS4059 now permits contamination limits to be identified in a variety of ways: • Identical to NAS 1638 — For example, AS4059 Class 8 is the same as NAS 1638 Class 8. e size of particles counted varies depending upon whether an optical micro- scope or light blockage APC is used. • Cumulative count above a specified size — Examples: AS4059 Class 8A, AS4059 Class 8B • Differential counts for various sizes — Examples: AS4059 Class 8B-D or Class 8A-D • Different classes for cumulative counts of particles greater than a particular size range — An example would be 7B/6C/5D or 7B/4C. ere isn't a right or wrong cleanliness standard to use when setting up a lubrication program. e important thing is that you follow a standard and use it correctly. Setting Cleanliness Targets Unlike most of the information in an oil analysis report, particle counts should not use the same trending methods of iron, silica, copper, etc. You will want to watch which direction your particle counts are moving, but this alone should not be used as a failure indicator. ere are just too many variables in play. e difference between codes can be one particle or several hundred or thousand particles. For this reason, it is recommended to set cleanliness targets and track particle counts or ISO codes relative to those targets. Both cautionary and critical alarm limits should be established. Ideally, the cautionary limit will be your target or one code above. e alarm limit might be two or three codes above your target. ese limits will help make your decision-making process easier if you should consider cleaning your oil with a filter cart or performing a full drain, flush and fill. Setting cleanliness targets for each lubricant offers many benefits. e main advantage is the extension of overall machine life, which can lower maintenance costs and increase production cycles. Case studies have shown particle contamination to be the leading cause of machine failures. erefore, it only makes sense to monitor the concen- tration of these particles. Other benefits of setting cleanliness targets include increasing the awareness and visibility of the efforts being made through various lubrication activities. Establishing a moderately aggressive target for your lubricants will require everyone to follow lubrication best practices. It can also create a common goal among maintenance and operations personnel for plants in which the lubrication duties are spread across multiple departments or divisions. Since not all machines are treated equally, it will be important that cleanliness targets be set appropriately for each machine. For example, hydraulic and turbine systems are far more sensitive to solid contaminants than a gearbox or process pump. e oil's viscosity will also play a significant role. e higher the viscosity, the more difficult it will be to remove particles. e machine's environment can impact your cleanliness targets as well. A hydraulic system in a controlled environment, such as a pharmaceutical production area, may have a different target than the same hydraulic system inside a cement plant. More potential contaminants in the air can increase the need to maintain cleaner oils, which will require a more aggressive standard. A high-con- taminant area may also demand a larger investment to help maintain the appropriate oil cleanliness levels. Most original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) provide general lubricant cleanliness levels for their machines to meet the warranty expectations. While these OEM targets make for a great starting point, they often do not take into consideration your specific environ- ment or plant reliability goals. If your facility has a centralized lube room, set an overall cleanliness target for each oil type. When establishing these targets, begin with the most sensitive machine component using each oil and work through the same process for each machine. Once you have set your cleanliness targets, take a stepped approach to cleaning your oils. Starting with a high-efficiency filter at a small micron level would be expensive. Instead, slowly progress to smaller micron filters over time. When you reach your goal, you can then maintain this cleanliness level with higher efficiency filters. By better understanding the cleanliness code, setting appropriate targets and closely monitoring your particle counts, you can determine how dirty or clean your oil is, which should then help you achieve your overall reliability goals. References Fitch, E.C. (1976). "e New ISO Clean- liness Code – Let's Use It." Fluid Power Research Conference. Day, M. "What Happened to NAS 1638?" Practicing Oil Analysis, December 2002. International Standard 4406:87. Inter- national Organization for Standardization. International Standard 4406:99. Inter- national Organization for Standardization. About the Author Devin Jarrett is an account manager at Noria Corporation. He holds a Level II Machine Lubrication Technician (MLT ) certification and a Level III Machine Lubri- cant Analyst (MLA) certification through the International Council for Machinery Lubri- cation (ICML). Contact Devin at djarrett@ noria.com to learn how Noria can help you establish cleanliness targets for your lubricants. BACK PAGE BASICS START YOUR FREE SUBSCRIPTION www.machinerylubrication.com

