ICT Today

ICT Today October/November/December 2020

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1284149

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 13 of 79

14 I ICT TODAY radio signals. These fundamental differences in design have historically created a divergence in the applications of these technologies; Wi-Fi is normally used indoors, whereas cellular is normally used outdoors. However, there are many other considerations involved in comparing these two general approaches to wireless connectivity: • Cost: Because the licensing of cellular technolo- gies makes cellular infrastructure more expensive for clients, Wi-Fi has a distinct advantage in terms of deployment costs. Also, Wi-Fi typically avoids the subscriber costs associated with paying a network operator to use its infrastructure and licensed spectrum. • Ubiquity: Wi-Fi is everywhere. With its backwards compatibility, its evolving infrastructure ensures that investments in legacy devices are protected. This contrasts with cellular chipsets, which usually support only the latest generations of devices. The result is that there are billions more Wi-Fi devices in operation than cellular devices. • Ease of Deployment: The two technologies' divergent allegiances to licensed and unlicensed spectrum mean very different levels of speed and complexity in deployment. Wi-Fi can be set up in minutes by most consumers, whereas cellular still requires skilled administration. • Coverage and Mobility: Because of the aforemen- tioned differences in design objectives between cellular and Wi-Fi, cellular has evolved to deliver wider outdoor coverage that can handle highly mobile devices. Wi-Fi thrives indoors but is most effective for short-range connectivity. • Cadence of Innovation: Historically, Wi-Fi has evolved faster than cellular via a technology refresh cycle every five years versus cellular's 10-year cadence. As bandwidth use continues to grow and as demanding new applications take hold, these innovation cycles will dictate the ability of each technology to cater to evolving global demands. Wi-Fi 6E AND 5G In addition to the traditional tradeoffs of cellular versus Wi-Fi, the evolution to 5G and Wi-Fi 6E has introduced new features and capabilities that further blur the lines between the two technologies. In fact, as cellular and Wi-Fi have evolved, they have also begun to converge and share innovation. Some examples include OFDMA, multi-user MIMO (MU-MIMO), and beamforming, which are used across modern forms of both networks to manage growing data and device traffic and to improve transmission rates. The FCC's release of 6 GHz unlicensed spectrum, in addition to boosting the capabilities of Wi-Fi, also provides a new outlet for 5G to offload traffic. Even though cellular networks traditionally run on licensed spectrum, they can also use unlicensed spectrum to supplement bandwidth and coverage. When Wi-Fi 6E and 5G are compared, there are some very obvious similarities and advantages to each approach: • Speed: Wi-Fi 6E supports a peak data rate of 9.6 Gb/s, which is comparable to 5G, but Wi-Fi 6E also achieves a spectral efficiency of 62.5 bps/Hz, more than double that of 5G's specified 30 bps/Hz. • Delivery: Both standards are capable of supporting the latest and most demanding AR, VR, and IoT applications (e.g., telemedicine) through high-speed data rates and extremely low latency. Both also support new protocols to extend the battery life of associated client devices. • Density: This is one area where Wi-Fi unequivo- cally comes out on top. Wi-Fi 6E works very well for extremely dense environments, such as stadi- ums, campuses, and large venues. A single Wi-Fi 6E WAP, for example, can serve up to 1,024 clients concurrently. Its trigger frame feature, which is related to OFDMA, enables scheduled access and results in improved transmission, bringing its reliability in line with 5G's.

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of ICT Today - ICT Today October/November/December 2020