Sport Rocketry

Sport Rocketry 2.2021

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1345417

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 15 of 47

16 MARCH/APRIL 2021 SPORT ROCKETRY stability. Changing the fins to 2cm elliptical brought the mass in the simulation down to 12.8 grams and the altitude to 188m. Better, but still not 200 meters and with the too short of delay, I was unlikely to achieve 200 meters with this somewhat haphaz- ardly arrived at "optimal" design. I needed to get more mass out, and/or reduce drag while keeping the rocket stable. From the test launch and Zoom meeting, I knew Tom was using 10 mil (0.01") thick G10 for his 1/2A Altitude rockets. This would both lightened up the rocket and reduce drag. So I switched to 10 mil G10 in my sim and observed that I could also make the fins smaller and still keep the rocket stable because the thinner fins reduced the weight at the backend of the rocket and Figure 4 (Left). Simulation of "200 Meters or Bust" 1/2A Altitude rocket. Weighing 12 grams, it simulated to an altitude of 205 meters but the Open Rocket simulation does not factor in the early ejection or using a piston. ejection occurs at around 175 meters. See the simulation of the new design in figure 4. Would the piston help to push it over 200 meters even with the too-short delay? I decided to build this version and see if I could break 200 meters. But our WOOSH launches were shut down due to the pan- demic! Finally, Wisconsin reopened and at the WOOSH NRC launch on June 6, and I was able to try "200 Meters or Bust" as I called this design. The boost was good but not quite perfectly straight up. However, at ejection the body tube separated from the nose cone/altimeter. Fortunately the streamer was attached to the nose section. The body tube with spent engine tumbled in safely. It only weighed about 5 grams. I was truly happy when I saw that the ALT- BMP reported an altitude of 213.7 meters. After temperature compensation the actual altitude was 221 meters! More than the simulation! A hot engine or a good piston launch? Perhaps both. Using the NAR S&T data for the delay, the simulation data says the altitude was 182 meters at a 3-second ejection delay. It also shows the velocity at ejection was 24 m/s. This is a little fast and probably was a factor in the shock cord breaking. More on that in a bit. In our WOOSH Zoom meeting, we also discussed weighing engines and us- ing the heaviest one. There are two ideas here. One, the extra weight is due to ex- tra propellant, and two, the extra weight is due to a longer delay element. Both of which are desirable. Of course it could be due to a heavier nozzle, heavier casing, extra ejection charge, or extra clay in the cap. Research projects in this area seem to be inconclusive. Nevertheless, I chose the heaviest 1/2A3-4T I had handy to make the flight. It weighed 6.8 grams, which is the S&T published weight. But my other 1/2A3-4Ts weighed 6.4 to 6.6 grams. Is the CG moved forward. After some try- ing different fins sizes out in Open Rocket, the fins ended up being elliptical with a 16mm root chord and a span of 21 mm. That also brought the mass down to 12.5 grams. I made one final change to reduce weight. That was peeling the inside layer of paper out of the body tube. Bernard Biales published an article in the Jan/ Feb 1972 issue of Model Rocketry maga- zine about this. You can read it at http:// www.ninfinger.org/rockets/ModelRocket- ry/Model_Rocketry_v04n04_(01-02)-72. pdf. That took another 0.5 grams of mass out so the final mass of this optimized ver- sion is about 12 grams and simulates at 205 meters altitude. However, it looks like Figure 5. Picture of the "200 Meters or Bust" rocket after launch with scale and flight card. Mission accomplished as the rocket achieved and altitude of 221 meters! Figure 6 (Above right). Plot from data download from the altimeter. Spikes in the data are caused by exposure of the sensor on the altimeter to sunlight as the nose section turns on descent. The Adrel filter function removes those so an accurate altitude reading can be made.

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Sport Rocketry - Sport Rocketry 2.2021