BizEd

MayJune2007

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/58061

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 43 of 75

"The intelligence isn't in the game. It's around the table." —James Chisholm of ExperiencePoint used to provide assessment data useful for accreditation; the company plans to meet with representatives of accrediting bodies to refine the game for that purpose. "The first time students participate in a simulation, it's a lab. They're learning from their mistakes, so the game can't be used to evaluate their skill level," says MSI's Smith. "But the second time they participate in that simulation and answer questions about their decisions, on a standardized playing field, it's a test of competence." For Meadows, the real test for students is what they do with the knowledge they gain through simulated experi- Old Game, New Tech Carleton University's Sprott School of Business in Ottawa, Canada, is using a business simulation to reach students who are still deciding on their future careers: high school students. Its 2007 Sprott Business Competition (SBC) brought together 10,000 high schoolers from across Ontario and Manitoba. The competition itself is actually 22 years old. In 1986, 200 high school students participated in the first SBC, send- ing in their quarterly decisions on a weekly basis via voice message and fax. Teaching assistants manually entered the information into a mainframe computer. The resulting data was then rekeyed into the Lotus 1-2-3 spreadsheet program, printed out, and sent by courier back to the students. What a difference 22 years make. In 2001, the school offered its first Web-enabled competition. In 2005, the game was redesigned in an online format, allowing thousands of students to participate in the challenge from their home schools. This year, students led virtual companies that manu- facture MP3 players. Each team began with $70,000 in market share and $30,000 in working capital; they submit- ted their quarterly decisions online twice a week over two months. The best teams compete in a playoff in May. SBC is a free outreach program that "balances theory with practice to make business classes more fun," says Rob Riordan, a Sprott professor. In addition, high school students learn what it's like to be in business. Michelle O'Brien, now a student at Sprott, participated in SBC three times as a high school student and took its lessons to heart. "The game is part of the reason I chose to take business at Carleton University," she says. 42 BizEd MAY/JUNE 2007 ences. "The last step for faculty is to get a commitment from students that they're going to make changes based on what they've learned from the game," Meadows says. "There's no point using a simulation to generate insight if the students aren't going to act on it." Implications of Simulations Professors who are interested in doing more with serious gaming can look forward to new products that make it even easier to bring simulations into the classroom. Soon, says Chisholm of ExperiencePoint, they will have the technology at hand to create their own games, in much the same way as they would design their own Web site using a Web publish- ing program. "The question we're asked the most is, 'Do you have a game in this discipline?' Up until six months ago, we would answer, 'We can build that game, but it will cost a lot of money!' But we're now redesigning the engine to allow pro- fessors to create their own games, in a do-it-yourself model," he says. ExperiencePoint plans a soft launch of its game pub- lishing product in August at the Academy of Management's 2007 Annual Conference in Philadelphia. The biggest advantage of management simulations may be their impact on business students. Few experiences offer students such immediate insight on their strengths and weaknesses. When done right, simulations cut away the busywork that can accompany business transactions and put key issues in sharp relief, says Meadows. "With computer Capstone is a simulation from Management Simulations Inc. that puts students at the helm of a multidimensional company, where they must take into account financial reporting, market fluctuations, and other data to execute a business plan successfully.

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of BizEd - MayJune2007