BizEd

JulyAugust2003

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/62203

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 32 of 67

Allowing learning assessment to become punitive defeats its very purpose—which is to help all educators improve their games. point—and even punish—underperforming faculty will find themselves in an Enron-like situation very quickly. When per- formance is measured to reward the good and punish the bad, employees not only become resentful and anxious, they also learn very quickly to tell administrators what they want to hear. Allowing learning assessment to become punitive defeats its very purpose—which is to help all educators improve their games. The main challenge in the early stages of implementing an assessment program is thus to reassure faculty that such retal- iation for weak performance is not going to happen. lum. Each business major took those courses, so it seemed logical to focus our efforts there and develop a methodology to chart their progress. Initially, the biggest challenge for faculty was to determine Administrators must assure faculty that the data collected through assessment will not be used for promotion and tenure decisions, but rather, are tools for the collective improvement of the business school's educational offerings. Paranoia No. 2: Even after they are successfully reassured about Paranoia No. 1, faculty members start to worry about their time investment. No faculty member wants to waste time on something that will never be used. Therefore, the next challenge in putting assessment practices in place is to make clear that the extra effort faculty members invest will result in positive change. Learning assessment must eventual- ly be consequential, leading to changes in curriculum and approaches when course objectives are not being met. Mature assessment systems do have built-in levels of accountability—after all, if a professor shows poor per- formance for a long period of time, he should not be allowed to continue. But, in most cases, assessment pro- adjustments in the course. We've been doing much better, and we will continue to take steps to develop the course. We have another faculty member whose first score was what the objectives for each course were. Many of our faculty had been teaching a long time—they knew what they wanted to teach and what they wanted to accomplish, but it was real- ly all in their heads. It was like cooking without a recipe— we know what it looks like when it's finished, but we're not sure how we got there! To have the faculty come together to write down specific objectives in a formal statement was a difficult task. We recently received our outcomes assessment for the fall semester of 2002. Our operational management course received an overall score of 71 percent, with seven out of 20 questions in the "watch" category, and four requiring action. The interesting thing with this course is that we have new faculty teaching it, so we need to revisit the objectives to make sure they still match the objectives of the current pro- fessors. We have another course in managerial accounting that has caused us concern. Of the 11 objectives we have set for the course, two fell below 50 percent, and five were between 50 and 70 percent. The overall score for the course was 62 percent. That 62 percent shows that there is still much room for in the upper 80s. Even though his course was well past the "acceptable" rating, he still wanted to improve. So, he used the results to make his class better. His score is now at 93 percent. In many cases, however, I might be as concerned with a course that consistently stays in the 95 percent-range as I would with one that falls in the 60-percent range. You have to monitor both high and low scores for a period of time to make sure the course is really working. Our next step is to expand course-embedded assessment improvement, but the course started with a rating of 42 percent! As a result of assessment practices, the professor began to mon- itor what he was teaching and examine his objectives to make to the rest of the business curriculum to include electives and required courses for business disciplines. Eventually, it will go campuswide. It's a long process, but schools just need to start some- where—pilot a small program in just the core classes, or even in just one class. What schools will probably find is that setting up course-embedded assessments is as time- consuming as setting up Internet-based learning. But such assessments will provide benefits in the long run, giving schools a track record of how they're doing. I do feel that we're among the pioneers of learning assessment. Many people will do it differently and perhaps do it better than we have. But we will continue to improve our process—and I believe it's very important that we've been brave enough to look. BizEd JULY/AUGUST 2003 31

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of BizEd - JulyAugust2003