Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1544305
20 April 2026 Inhalation convenient mass flow rate. Also, ideally, the angle of the expansion after the constricting gap is not so abrupt that the gas density decreases enough to induce super-sonic flow velocities with their atten- dant energy losses. So the slope of the walls of the body and of the base of the valve stem significantly affect the ability to approximate "reversible and adia- batic" air flow through the gap. It is also unavoidable that the gap is annular, and that geometry creates an annular downstream air flow shape, rather than a circular jet depicted in Figure 4, as the air stream flows over the base of the valve stem and moves out of the valve. e air streamlines meet on the other side of the valve stem in a controlled but irregular manner, another one of many practical realities that work against the ideal situation envisioned in Figure 4 with its "adiabatic and reversible" conditions. Even if the physical design issues could simulate the flow conditions of Figure 4, it is important to ask, "Is the flow sonic simply because P d /P u is smaller than 0.5?" One might have high confidence in the hypothetical example of Figure 4. But the pressure gauges in Figure 5 depict another issue one faces with real equipment, namely that the measurements of the upstream pressure and of the downstream pres- sure do not take place immediately before and after the flow-restricting gap. Real equipment requires these pressures to be measured at some convenient locations (shown in Figure 5 to the left and to the right of the flow control valve; each gauge here is reading a pres- sure relative to atmospheric). Even if test personnel wanted to measure the pressure just upstream and just downstream of the flow restricting gap, it would be very difficult to create small channels to access these situation, so the term itself does have a conceptual value in the inhaler testing community, even though no one actually measures this velocity at any point in any valve nor in any flow control equipment. e bottom line is simply this—the assumptions of adiabatic, isentropic flow of an ideal gas allows the air flow velocity to reach the speed of sound in a con- verging nozzle when the pressure ratio r reaches a cer- tain value (equation 7) that maximizes the mass flow rate of air. It is from this approximate analysis that the word "sonic" emerges, and it is from the math of this analysis that the word "critical" emerges. "Ideal versus real" control valve shape e thoughtful reader will anticipate that the approx- imations described in the analysis above, including the approximation of a converging nozzle shape, will not hold as well for real flow control valves as they do in the hypothetical converging nozzle in Figure 4. A real needle valve has a stem that retracts when the user rotates the handle in a counter-clockwise direction (Figure 5). A small adjustable gap forms between the stem and the wall of the valve body. With a pressure drop across the valve, air accelerates as it approaches this gap and can theoretically reach, in some circum- stances, sonic velocity at the narrowest point of the gap. at is the idea of flow control via a needle valve. e design of such a flow control valve requires thinking about how best to make the air flow path inside the valve approximate a converging nozzle that leads to a final gap; and for the inhaler testing appli- cation, the size of the gap needs to restrict the flow velocity, ideally to a fixed, possibly sonic, speed at a Figure 5 Flow path through a typical needle valve P u P d Flow Body Handle Valve Stem Body Seats Gap

