Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1544305
Inhalation April 2026 15 Frustrated User: Too much jargon; too many foot- notes! Are there any data in the open literature on these matters of importance? In this article, we assist our hypothetical, now frus- trated, user by a) showing a method of testing inhaler flow control valves, b) showing test data for the Parker valve 8FV12LN, c) explaining the reasons for the confusing terminology (sonic, choked, crit- ical) that typifies discussions of proper flow control and d) explaining why the valve test method in the pharmacopeia is irrelevant to inhaler testing. Overall, the article emphasizes the need for testing and under- standing flow control valves that are in routine use for setting the flow rate for DPI testing. Apparatus for testing valve performance Figure 2 depicts a simple apparatus for testing a valve for the conditions under which the flow rate reaches a maximum value at fixed upstream conditions, a flow rate that does not increase regardless of how much one reduces the downstream pressure with a vacuum pump, no matter how powerful the vacuum pump. Operationally and for meeting regulatory purposes, this condition of "does not increase" is a sufficient and valuable definition of "choked." e equipment shown does not determine if the flow rate reaches the speed of sound at the control valve. And there is nothing about the flow that is measured to be "criti- cal" in any sense of the word. (More content appears below on the words "critical" and "sonic.") Parker's online catalog has a good set of specifica- tions for this class of valve (https://www.parker.com/ content/dam/Parker-com/Literature/Instrument ation-Products-Division/Catalogs/IPD_Needle_ Valves_Catalog_4110-NV.pdf ). On page 6 of this online catalog, the reader can find that Cv is indeed larger than 1 (Figure 1, which is an excerpt of the table on page 6 of the Parker catalog). And in the footnote to this table, the reader can see that the test for Cv is in accordance with the same procedure as that called out in the USP, namely, ISA S75.02. is footnote to the table in the Parker catalog is quite important, and for this reason, we reproduce it here (with parentheses around P 1 -P 2 added for clarity): "Tested in accordance with ISA S75.02. Gas flow will be choked when (P 1 -P 2 )/P 1 = X T ." Realizing that P 1 in the footnote under the table of the Parker catalog (Figure 1) is the upstream pres- sure and P 2 is the downstream pressure, we see that the Parker catalog is saying that "choked" flow occurs when the ratio of downstream pressure to upstream pressure equals 1-X T . According to the table in Fig- ure 1, for valve 8FV12LN, choked flow occurs when X T is 0.83; and that means choked flow occurs when P 2 /P 1 = 1-X T = 0.17. So what happened to the tra- ditional, theoretical value of P 2 /P 1 smaller than or equal to 0.5? Or do we need to ask if "choked" is the same as "critical" and "sonic?" Figure 1 Specifications of a family of Parker Needle Valves, including 8FV12LN

