Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1544305
22 April 2026 Inhalation likely are irrelevant. Under the ISA S75.02 protocol then, there are several mechanisms by which energy is lost; and so it is not surprising that greater pumping power is needed (the smaller value of P d /P u ) to obtain choked flow conditions. Nevertheless, until the requisite testing equipment, protocol and data are explained in an open publica- tion, the exact reasons for the Parker specifications will remain unknown. As a result, we question the wisdom of including the Parker choked flow spec- ification and the ISA S75.02 protocol in the phar- macopeial compendia. Discussion and conclusions We have traced the meaning of several terms that describe the setting of the flow rate in the testing of dry powder inhalers, specifically "critical," "sonic" and "choked." Of these, the most practical and meaning- ful term is the word "choked," indicating an inabil- ity to increase the flow rate regardless of how strong the vacuum pump pulling the flow through the control valve. e phenomenon of "choked" allows personnel in a practicing inhaler testing laboratory to achieve the same flow rate from test to test and from technician to technician, exactly what a testing team wants for good quality data. It can be described as a "sufficient" condition for achieving the desired flow control. At the same time, it is not a "necessary" condition since there are many ways to control flow besides those typical of inhaler testing [20, 21]. e terms "critical" and "sonic" arise in an approx- imate thermodynamic analysis that likely does not is nearly fully open, allowing the user to extrapolate confidently to the condition of being fully open). e mass flow rate of air under these circumstances is rather large, 10x to 100x the mass flow rate that will pass through this valve under inhaler testing condi- tions. For this reason, additional and different equip- ment than that shown in Figure 2 would be needed to test the valve under the ISA S75.02 protocol and these test conditions would be unrelated to inhaler testing conditions. If we think about what the valve is like when it is fully open (Figure 6), it is easy to imagine the air flow aggressively passing around the valve stem and, with some swirling motion, passing out through the body of the valve that surrounds the valve stem. It then turns and moves to the exit port. So the "fully open valve" required under ISA S75.02 has a flow path and resistance to flow that is significantly different than the path depicted in Figure 5 for a controlling needle valve, wherein the gap and the upstream and down- stream shape of the flow are more carefully defined. In a fully open valve, rather than encountering a con- verging flow path leading to a specific point of con- striction, the air flows through the body of the valve with the stem retracted into the chamber from which the flow exits. is flow path is ill-defined and can consist of preferred channels of flow with residence times much less than average (and some much larger). And downstream of the narrowest constriction, the flow could become supersonic, with significant energy loss in the attendant shock. In this environment, the approximations of adiabatic and isentropic flow very Figure 6 Flow path through a wide-open flow control valve P u P d Flow Body Handle Valve Stem Body Seats Gap

