BizEd

JulyAugust2004

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/61375

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 39 of 67

of education increases, will management education once again become the exclusive domain of the elites? And as new barriers to education present themselves—such as more restrictive visa requirements, funding con- straints, environmental dangers—how will business schools make sure their educational offerings reach all of their potential markets? Two areas especially—experiential learn- ing and the global distribution of knowl- edge—could help business schools solve these dilemmas in ways that benefit everyone seeking a business education, Czinkota pointed out. He agreed with Hamel that business schools must choose now which conventions make them stronger and which should be jettisoned for good. business school community must take to heart—and quick- ly. There is a sense of immediacy because for-profit institu- tions are already implementing innovations that reach this demographic, threatening to step in where business schools have traditionally feared to tread. One prominent example is the University of Phoenix, a "Traditional business schools have been intentionally designed to have inertia, to focus on long-term issues and not get caught up in fads. It is especially impor- tant that we avoid undue emphasis on the manage- ment style du jour." William F. Sharpe 38 BizEd JULY/AUGUST 2004 than to become "radical innovators" for businesses worldwide, the panelists agreed. To serve a shift- ing customer demographic, business schools must offer stu- dents real-world experience, greater access to information, expanded use of technology, a higher level of skill develop- ment, and more sophisticated global perspectives. That's no small task, said Hamel, but it's one that the INNOVATE! There is no greater task for business schools "Business schools … are often more glorified journalists than anything else. If business schools want to be relevant, they have to be seen as making an impact. They have to be seen as the inventors of new management practice." Gary Hamel powerhouse organization with a decided- ly contrarian approach to higher educa- tion. In just a few years, and in spite of its detractors, the online educational provider has developed a national presence, building market capital of more than $13 billion and establishing more than 140 campuses. Business schools can perceive the U of Phoenix either as a threat or as an exam- ple of how far innovation can take an institution in a fluctuating market, Hamel suggested. "Not to hold it up as an exem- plar for education," he said, "but the University of Phoenix illustrates that there is enormous potential for innovation in education, if people are willing to think in new ways." DON'T follow fads. The panelists agreed that a percentage of the business school enterprise through the same lens as commercial organizations can lead to a skewed understanding of market realities. It can also create false expectations for what business schools should be and do, said the strategists. "Jumping on bandwagons," so to speak, is better left to those industries that can afford to miss long- term opportunities. "Educational institutions can provide information and market will go to radical innovators who are better positioned to satisfy shifting market demands. Without attention to long-term issues, however, the competitive advantage innovation presents quickly dissipates. One only has to think of the roaring "dot-com '90s" to know that style can't survive long without substance in business. Pairing innovation with issues of lasting significance is crucial. Innovation, then, should be handled with care. Viewing the traditional management education experience that is similar to that gained in the real world, but their comparative advantage lies in large part in other areas," said William F. Sharpe, the Timken Professor Emeritus of Finance at the Stanford Graduate School of Business and win- ner of the 1990Nobel Prize in economics. "This is not to den- igrate emphases on leadership, entrepreneurship, manage- ment, and global business. Both traditional and newer institu- tions will do more in these areas in the future. But traditional business schools have been intentionally designed to have iner- tia, to focus on long-termissues and not get caught up in fads.

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of BizEd - JulyAugust2004