Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/61375
ducting academic experiments designed to develop new methods and tools for use in business—to see what works and what doesn't—and come up empty-handed. "As far as I know, no one has yet created a model for of laboratory experiment to see how they react to different kinds of incentives," Hamel commented. "But in business schools, we haven't done this very much. So we are often more glorified journalists than anything else. If business schools want to be relevant, they have to be seen as mak- ing an impact. They have to be seen as the inventors of new management practice." Hamel has searched for business schools that are con- business teaching and research that is both aspirational and experimental. To invent, one needs both. One needs to work in the real world with smart people, imagine some- thing that doesn't exist, and create it," Hamel said. "There's enormous room for innovation in this area; but it won't be easy and it certainly won't be quick." es. Many business schools tout their global programs with great fervor. There's only one problem, said these pan- elists. In many cases, many schools are more global in word than in deed. "Business schools all like to believe they are global and GLOBALIZE—really. Globalization is the biggest buzzword on b-school campus- employees to work in other countries. "To be global, business schools need significant facilities on at least three conti- nents," said Michael Enright, Sun Hung Kai Properties Professor and director of the Asia- Pacific Competitiveness Program at the Univer- sity of Hong Kong. Then, schools need to base promotions on the fulfillment of long-term teaching and research obligations in all three regions, he said. Most important, they have an international focus," said Hamel. "But for many of them, the first rule is that all faculty must live within 50 miles of the head office. What global business in the world starts out by saying everybody we hire has to live within 50 miles of our campus?" Part of the problem is a narrow—and traditional—defini- redefine their notions of faculty hiring and development, pan- elists argued. It's one area where they do want to emulate lead- ing multinational companies, which routinely send their 40 BizEd JULY/AUGUST 2004 must ask themselves what it means to build a truly global faculty. "What would it mean to build a school that used satellite technology to reach thousands of people at a time?" he asked. "There is a great deal of innovation possible, in all kinds of ways, if we have the courage to challenge our his- torical assumptions." To achieve true global character, business schools need to tion of a university as an institution that is geographically constrained and identified with a single city or region. As a result, every university has to support an entire faculty on its own because it can't borrow faculty from somewhere else. It's a system that is quickly becoming outdated. With that in mind, Hamel continued, all business schools need to rethink one of the most highly cher- ished traditions in high- er education—tenure. "Tenure might have to be abolished to ensure that the 'groupthink' of people in the same job and location for 25 or 30 years does not dominate," Enright said. "In this market, we may have a situation in which small business schools that haven't changed much in the last several centuries may compete successfully against radical new models of organization." Ernest Scalberg maybe too much. While accelerated cycles of innovation in most business sectors can't be ignored, all the talk of change has created an environment where many schools are pursuing change for its own sake, the gurus said. Instead, the modern business school should be creating meaningful change. The concept of "radical innovation" may imply extreme FORM THE FUTURE—don't follow it. Much has been said about the rapid pace of change— measures, they noted, but its practice means something much different. So-called radical innovation requires rea- soned moderation—in choosing innovations that lead to growth, eschewing old conventions that constrain, and establishing a culture that embraces experimentation. These fundamental tasks are designed to transform the modern business school into a powerhouse of ideas for business, these strategists suggested. Implementing these measures is, at best, formidable. Their purpose, however, is to help busi- ness schools avoid the worst: irrelevance. s z

