BizEd

JulyAugust2004

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/61375

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 33 of 67

"Executive education revolves around what the client What skills do they want their employees to gain, and what's the most cost-effective way to teach those skills?" —Diane Badame, University of Southern California MBA Council, and she notes an interesting trend in the Council's student satisfaction surveys. Fewer students are giv- ing their schools the highest ratings in terms of performance and value than they did in years past.Although the drop is only by a few points, she thinks the dip is significant. "If you have to pay for the degree yourself, you want more," she says. an EMBA—and pay for it themselves. Some of these con- sumers are even more demanding than corporations, believes Diane Badame, associate dean for the executive MBA and MBA for Professionals and Managers programs at the University of Southern California in Los Angeles. She is also co-chair of theResearchCenter for the Executive Lo-Cal MBA Yet another interpretation of the lowered statistics in student satisfaction is that EMBA programs aren't quite what they used to be. As more students go it alone, they're desperate to complete the programin less time. This has led to shorter and shorter EMBA programs—and the contention that many such programs are "MBA lite." There's no disputing the first charge. While EMBA Council statistics show that the average program length is 20 months, fewer schools are meeting that target. In 2000, 51 percent of programs were 21 to 22 months; that number dropped to 37 percent in 2003. "Shorter programs are springing up," says Badame. "To me that promotes the lack of rigor and a degrading of the degree." Some defend the trend as being a response to two contra- by squeezing out days off at holidays and in the summer. "This will work for individuals except those few who really have 50- hour-a-week noncompressable jobs," Bishop says. "Many peo- ple will work at a nonsustainable pace for 16 months." Others find the trend worrisome. "Our program is 54 dictory market pressures. "First, there's been a wider recog- nition of an EMBA as the route to a qualityMBA, so demand is growing," Bishop says. "Second, people havemore work to do and less time to do it, so they want to do everything faster. That puts a lot of pressure on EMBA programs to shorten elapsed time and reduce class contact hours." Ivey has condensed its own EMBA program to 16 months to get into at Pace than the MBA program. "I get calls from people saying, 'I don't know if I can qualify for your program. Do you think I can hold my own?'" It's true that EMBA stu- dents are pampered—with good food and cushy accommoda- tions—but Parker says, "You can't translate that intoMBA lite, not in the terms of the work they do! There's no place you can hide in a class with 25 people who are all hard-chargers." an EMBA program remains high, she says. "If we just take anyone who's willing to pay the price, the other students could suffer," she says. Parker agrees, noting that the EMBA is a harder program Indistinct Parameters Another charge leveled against executive education programs is that boundaries are beginning to blur between EMBAs and executive education as degreed programs grow shorter and nondegreed programs grow more complex. While fewer employers want to pay high prices for their employees to receive an EMBA, they still want key employees to learn essential skills. Looking for a less pricey source of business education, they often turn to nondegree programs. "Executive education revolves around what the client real- credits. I don't know of any program that requires less than 46 or 48 credits. If you start cutting back on the time tomake the program more attractive, how can you cram everything in?" asks Parker. To guard against any suspicion that an EMBA program is tives—want programs of academic rigor, says Elena Liquete, executive director of the Global Executive MBA at IESE Business School in Barcelona, Spain. "People in the executive program really understand what they're in for. I think they'd be quite disappointed if we didn't make them work so hard," she says. "My students would be most offended if people thought they were getting away lightly." Tough admissions standards help ensure that the quality of University of Chicago. "Are the faculty the same as they are in the full-time program? Are students being evaluated in the same way? What degree do the students earn? Clearly, if the faculty, evaluation process, and degree are all the same between programs, this would dispel any concern about whether an EMBA isMBA lite," he says. EMBA students—who are highly motivated senior execu- a low-calorie version of an MBA program, the EMBA pro- gram must be held to the same standards, says William Kooser, associate dean for part-time MBA programs at the 32 BizEd JULY/AUGUST 2004 ences between the two types of programs.One key distinction is the fact that nondegree programs usually have open enroll- ment, while EMBA programs have high admission standards. Another is the very fact that a degree is awarded—but there's a little confusion on that front, too. ly wants," Badame says. "What skills do they want their employees to gain, and what's the most cost-effective way to teach those skills?" Yet no business seminar can teach execu- tives everything they need to know. "You can't get an MBA in a week's time. It's just not possible," she says. Administrators think it's important to point out the differ-

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of BizEd - JulyAugust2004