BizEd

JulyAugust2004

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/61375

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 46 of 67

Fired! to our teaching. There is the descriptive element, in which we show our students real-world examples so they see and under- stand how the real business world operates. And there is the normative element, through which we have an obligation to discuss how our students should operate in the real business world. Striking the right balance between the descriptive and normative elements of business education is critical. That is, our students should understand that some actions are desirable not just because they are legal, but because they are good for the company, shareholders, employees, and society. To address both of these issues, context and follow-up are critical. In the case of "The Apprentice," it's difficult to place the Apprentice" represents good business, they, too, may be missing the point. As business faculty, wemust always include two dimensions showin the appropriate context or find the time to conduct suf- ficient follow-up.Wemay not have the time to ask what, exact- ly, students are learning from the show. Perhaps more impor- be one large infomercial for the Trump empire—rent a Trump apartment or penthouse belonging to Trump, drum up busi- ness at Trump's Taj Mahal, use the ice rink that was saved by "The Donald," and sell Trump-endorsed bottled water. Of in a zero-sumenvironment. At the end of the show there can be only one winner. This distills business down to a pure Hobbesian vision of "one against all." Trump's television creation is particularly pernicious because the audience is led to believe that participants are functioning not only as busi- nesspeople do function in the real world, but as they should— all under the guise of reality. Not tomention that, at times, "The Apprentice" appears to lemonade onWall Street, operating a fleamarket, negotiating the best price for items recovered in a scavenger hunt—would be rejected bymost advisors to a Junior Achievement chapter. Yet these tasks passed as those that should be used to select a division president in Trump's empire. Let us also not forget that each contestant is functioning Are we to assume that to break the glass ceiling, women should rely more on a pair of stiletto heels than on talent and intelligence? What a wonderful message to send to business students. rily at students, but at the business community and society at large. For example, with this in mind, Quinnipiac University's School of Business inHamden, Connecticut, recently initiated a four-year program that aims to balance the real world of business with the contextualization of that world in the class- room. We want students to learn not just about business, but about how to function successfully in that community, some- thing that the so-called reality of "The Apprentice" does not provide. tant, as business educators,wemay not have time to ask ourselves whether the lessons of "The Apprentice" actually represent any normative directions for functioning in the business world. As business educators, we aren't aiming our services prima- anticipate something of interest and value. But unfortunately, we are provided only periodic, seemingly trenchant insights fromTrump, such as "you have to believe in a product in order to sell it." Given this marvelous opportunity to expose the American public and our students to business, is it toomuch to expect something beyond such banalities? Perhaps it is. After all, in an era in which Spencer Johnson's Reality Television—Not Real Business A key element in the program's success is its presentation as reality television—we are led to believe that we are viewing the operation of a real business enterprise. But we shouldn't for- get that all the contestants were picked for their photogenic qualities and their media-friendly personalities. Or that many, if not most, of the tasks assigned to the contestants—selling course,Trump shouldn't be taken to task simply because he has been remarkably successful in marketing himself. In fact, it could be said that he has turned himself into a successful and powerful brand. For this very reason, when Trump speaks on the show, we WhoMovedMy Cheese? will probably outsell JimCollins' From Good to Great, you don't have to be a Laputan academic to realize that the facile and superficial often trumps, if you'll par- don the pun, substance and wisdom. German poet and histo- rian Friedrich von Schiller tells us, "Against stupidity the very gods themselves contend in vain." This may be true, but it is this struggle that should give the teaching professionmeaning. We shouldn't be expected to bow to the trivial just because it comes covered with a very thin patina of realism. BizEd JULY/AUGUST 2004 45

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of BizEd - JulyAugust2004