BizEd

JulyAugust2004

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/61375

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 48 of 67

Fired! meaningful business insights. Business education, on the other hand, must fill the void to make sure students aren't taking the show's message without qualification. For exam- ple, in Quinnipiac's new undergraduate business program, students are exposed to classroom-based business education in conjunction with a personal and professional development program. Students attend seminars, listen to a series of guest lectures, and discuss contemporary issues like ethics and gov- ernance with business leaders; those activities are then sup- plemented by a reading list that links classroom material and discussion to actual business practices. The program includes lessons in successful time management, business dinner eti- quette, and management of one's own future—students even learn to read The Wall Street Journal and use its information effectively. After class, they can use computer-assisted learning modules covering a variety of topics including using business research resources and navigating business interviews. Our students still learn the quantitative skills of business— probably provided much more in the way of useful and real- istic insights into business operations, particularly for business startups. But few if any business schools are discussing its con- tent in the classroom. Not surprisingly, its ratings weren't nearly as high. In fact, it's already been cancelled. "The Apprentice" falls short of offering our students Ironically, another NBC reality show, "The Restaurant," the numbers game of profit and loss that "The Apprentice" participants play so fervently. But in addition, they are encouraged to attend to their personal and career develop- ment and place these skills in a larger, meaningful context. This work sets the stage, beginning freshman year, for stu- dents to plan for personal and career success while recogniz- ing the importance of ethical behavior in business. men at such complex tasks as selling lemonade on Wall Street, developing an ad campaign, hawking shots in a bar off Times Square, and running a minimum-cost scavenger hunt. What Will Our Students Learn? So, let us review a few episodes of "The Apprentice," and ask ourselves what our students are most likely to learn. Starting in the first episode, the contestants were divided into two groups based upon gender. The concept of "men versus women" in a competitive environment functions at a particu- larly primal level. Women can feel empowered and men can prove their mettle. However, what's the lesson to be learned from this form of segregation? One wonders how NBC's Standards and Practice Committee would have responded had the show decided to separate the team on the basis of race. In the first four episodes, the women triumphed over the After these successes, Trump cautioned the women that they were relying too heavily on their sex appeal to win each task—and, of course, he wasn't being at all disingenuous. After the women again trounced the men in the fifth episode, Trump ordered a "corporate reshuffling." The gen- ders were now mixed into two teams. Television pundits enjoyed pointing out that when the women were in single- gender teams, they were aggressive and successful but engaged in a considerable amount of backbiting. Then, when teamed with the men, the women began to display passivity. This may not be a message we want to convey to our students. Add to this the fact that several of the women on the show ipants fail. Each episode's closing scenes in "the boardroom" are a nice display of social Darwinism in action. While this display may be an accurate description of how some teams function, I don't believe these methods would be effective for any large-scale, long-term project. The messages students might take from the first few work, a notion critical to business. Here we see many instances of very realistic behavior—teams forming through goal-driven activities, coalition formation, and conflict reso- lution. However, their environment is still highly artificial because someone has to win, which means that the long- term commitment of any one player to the notion of team- work is illusionary at best. Ultimately, it's to a participant's advantage if other partic- wound up in a men's magazine as lingerie models—posing in a business setting. Are we to assume that to break the glass ceiling, women should rely more on a pair of stiletto heels than on talent and intelligence?What a wonderfulmessage to send to female and male business students. Then there's the show's treatment of the concept of team- episodes are disturbing. Women executives should exploit sex, style triumphs over substance, knowledge of task and domain are secondary, political maneuvering and power are not only desirable but imperative—and they should do any- thing to win. Unfortunately, an argument can be made that these are truisms in business and dominate the actions of too many people in too many organizations. But while stu- dents need to know how the real world operates, we should- n't, in the interest of describing the real world, teach to the lowest common moral denominator. Those Two Little Words Finally, there's Trump's signature phrase, "You're fired," perhaps the cleverest part of the show. Each episode of "The Apprentice" ends with Trump terminating one of the partic- ipants, designed to build anticipation and interest in the BizEd JULY/AUGUST 2004 47

Articles in this issue

Archives of this issue

view archives of BizEd - JulyAugust2004