Inhalation

INH0426

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1544305

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 19 of 47

18 April 2026 Inhalation to zero [reference 18, page 187]. at point can be a local maximum or minimum value of the function or an inflection point. When we analyze the source of the word "sonic," below, we will explain exactly what func- tion whose derivative gives rise to the term "critical." We are confident that the inhaler testing community is generally not aware of this calculus. Furthermore, this calculus result is not tested by setting P d /P u to have a value smaller than 0.5. Finally, the term "crit- ical" does not describe the flow at all, and the inhaler testing community would lose no information (and even reduce some of the tension that inhaler testers and quality control personnel experience), if the term "critical" were dropped from the jargon of setting the flow rate in the testing of dry powder inhalers. To understand the source of the word "sonic," it is important first to define the speed of sound. e speed of sound is the speed at which a compression wave will pass through a gaseous medium and has nothing to do with how fast the gas may or may not be flowing. (ink of thunder, which is a noise that travels at about 1,000 ft/sec, much faster than wind speed). In a gas, the speed of sound is often given the symbol "c" and is defined by how the gas pressure changes when the gas density changes (equation 1): c = ∂P ∂ρ S (1) Equation 1 indicates the speed of sound is the square root of the change in pressure (P) when the density (r) changes and in a process with no change in the entropy (S). For an ideal gas, the simple relationships in equation 2 can be derived from equation 1: c = γ P = γ RT ρ MW (2) mercial equipment would ideally support the same conclusions regarding the onset of choked flow—but might not. In concept, one curve represents the char- acter of the valve (round data points), and one curve represents the character of the equipment (triangu- lar data points). Practicing inhaler testing personnel may be interested only in the performance of their test equipment or additionally in the performance of the stand-alone control valve. e ability to test commercial flow control equipment begs the ques- tion of specifications for suitability of the commer- cial equipment for its intended purpose. Currently, no such specifications exist. As a final point, we reiterate that the test method completely ignores the term "sonic" and the term "critical." e method does not call for the measure- ment of the velocity at any point to see if it reaches sonic speed and there is nothing that is "critical" any- where in the flow path. Critical? sonic? choked? Experimentally, the Parker valve 8FV12LN becomes choked at a ratio of P d /P u close to 0.5. So what are we to make of the Parker product literature that says that choked flow with this valve occurs when P d /P u is smaller than 0.17? is question must be addressed, but first it is essential to examine the underlying sources of the terms "critical," "sonic" and "choked," focusing the discussion on air flow under tempera- ture and pressure conditions typical of inhaler testing. e following discussion draws on thermodynamic principles articulated in what are now considered his- torical college-level textbooks [reference 16, section 8.5 and reference 17, chapter 4]. Of the terms "critical," "sonic" and "choked," "criti- cal" is the most removed from the practical realities of inhaler testing. is term is taken from calculus and is a point where the derivative of a function is equal Figure 4 Air flow through a converging nozzle P ambient P 0 P

Articles in this issue

view archives of Inhalation - INH0426