Inhalation

INH0426

Issue link: https://www.e-digitaleditions.com/i/1544305

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 22 of 47

Inhalation April 2026 21 team of inhaler testing personnel knows it has set its equipment to reach the condition where the flow is "choked," those team members can be confident that the mass flow rate of air will be the same test after test and for each user. For many reasons then, "choked" is far preferred as the term that describes the setting of the flow rate for testing dry powder inhalers. What about the specifications of valve 8FV12LN stated in its product literature? We can now return to the question, "How can the Parker product literature for valve 8FV12LN say that 'choked flow' takes place when P d /P u is equal to 0.17 or less?" Our data (Figure 3) says that the flow becomes choked when P d /P u is very nearly the theoretical ther- modynamic value of 0.528. Parker has an excellent technical reputation and very likely has unpublished data to back up the specifications in its product litera- ture. So, where do we turn for an explanation? We cannot be certain of the reasons for the Parker specification for choked flow. However, a plausible explanation lies in the test method that Parker has used (ISA S75.02; reference 19; see the footnote in Figure 1; and see section 8.2 of ISA S75.02 for the definition of "choked" flow). is protocol calls for the valve under test to be fully open when tested (or at least tested with enough data points where the valve points so as to attach pressure-measuring devices that can detect the pressure at these ideal locations. So we again must ask the question, "Is it correct to use the term 'sonic' when describing the flow through a control valve simply because P d /P u is smaller than 0.5?" Likely not. Finally, industry participants do not measure the air velocity near the exit of the flow con- trol gap and would find it rather expensive to mea- sure, even if they wished to do so. In the end, the air flow could be close to sonic when testing dry powder inhalers with current methods; but since the air flow velocity is not measured, the testing does not depend on whether the flow velocity is actually sonic. ese realities obviate the value of the term "sonic." e difficulties with "critical" and "sonic" are a major part of the reason that the term "choked" is much more practical, conveying the sense of what is hap- pening at the valve and why the flow is indeed con- trolled. e term "choked" has the advantage of being qualitative…it means "restricted" or "constrained" or "suppressed"…and all these terms convey what the user actually sees in the process of setting the flow rate for testing inhalers. It is also a term that can be measured and quantified with equipment like that in Figure 2. As described earlier, "choked" means that no matter how capable the system vacuum pump may be and how hard it may work, the mass flow rate of air will reach a maximum value and stay there, if the upstream conditions are constant. When a

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

view archives of Inhalation - INH0426